Skip to main content

1st Post, RPGaDay, and if it aint broke is it worth fixing?

So here after weeks of trying to get this blog off the ground, I have finally picked a name and started posting. This blog will contain my thoughts on tabletop rpgs, board games, and other games.  I am thinking I will include write ups of game sessions and even reviews of new products I try.  

At the beginning here I am also going to be writing with questions for you the reader as I work on my RPG I working on using the Awful Good Games Dice Pool rule set. The game is currently being called "Enchanted Kingdoms" and has 6 new/reworked classes and 16 "Bloodlines" or "Heritages" which takes the place of races.  It will include a ready to play campaign setting. I am going to have a few named kingdoms and towns but want to leave it open and vague enough that players and DMs have a lot of freedom. I will continue to discuss the game here as I work towards getting it onto Kickstarter in order to drum up the funds a professional art company. Shooting for some time between November and February, but we will see...

I was planning to use the RPG-a-day challenge to help me start posting every day for a little while. Even though I have missed the last 7 days of the challenge I will still try and use those to drive me towards a habit of posting and I will make up the missed ones as I go. Probably.

Today's RPG-a-Day is "what is a good RPG to play for 2 hour sessions or less?"  I am going to fudge this a little and give a few games.  Honestly any game can be played for only 2 hours if you have a good group.  You probably want some specifics though.  The one that kind of pushes the envelope on if it counts is Super Dungeon Explore.  An average game with set up is about 2 hours, and I am expecting their "Legends" RPG rules to be about the same. It has been my experience that games based on the Apocalypse/Dungeon World rule set work well for shorter sessions because of how flexible and fast their rules tend to be. Awful Good Games new Dungeons and Delvers "Black Book" containing streamlined d20 based rules also have worked well for our 2 hour sessions. 

Lastly let’s talk about a game that is not good for 2 hour sessions. It is my favorite edition of D&D 4th edition. I really love 4th edition, maybe I can talk about what I like about it on another day, but all of the moving parts on both sides of DM screen, especially in combat, make it ill-suited for short games.
Ok so after all that rambling I am going to end on the question I alluded to in the title of this post.  If it isn't broken is it worth the time and effort to fix it? I will probably come back to this question spotlighting other rules or mechanics but today I am thinking of the Attributes or Stats a game uses.  More specifically the number and names for those stats.  This comes up as I am trying to decide what to call attributes in the Enchanted Kingdoms game.  Many games nowadays run with the same six: Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, Intelligence, Wisdom, and Charisma.  Dice pool is intended to be a more simplified and approachable system that in the early stages had distilled those stats into Might, Agility, Intellect, and Grace.  However during development they decided they wanted 3 casting stats to help differentiate the different classes and it was changed to Might, Agility, Intellect, Spirit, and Charm. Also Grace is kind of confusing as it could mean the more physical grace as opposed to personality social grace. Personally I really like the simplified 4 stats but am not sure what to call them.  It would be simplest to go back to the most common stats and use Strength, Dexterity, Intelligence, and Charisma. But I did like the differentiating effect of having the renamed stats.  I even went so far as coming up with more eloquent versions Like Vigor, Elegance, Brilliance, and Allure. But then I remembered this version of the game was supposed to be able to also be played by a younger audience.  Now I am leaning towards Might, Grace, Intellect, and Charm.  But it could still be easier to use the more common Strength, Dexterity, Intelligence, and Charisma.  So what do you think? Which do you personally like better of those two?


Might
Grace
Intellect
Charm

Or

Strength
Dexterity
Intelligence
Charisma

And what are your thoughts on changing the names of stats in general?
Labels:

Comments

  1. UnknownAugust 8, 2017 at 7:13 PM

    Congratulations for starting a blog Adam.

    My opinion on the stats is that while obviously anything can work, by now people are very familiar with the D&D abilities, so differentiating should be done with care.

    I would Do

    Might Because it is more than just strength if you have no Constitution
    Dexterity/Agility Because Grace is too much associated with beauty
    Intellect/Mental Vague enough to cover a variety of mental applications
    Charm Works just fine for covering the usually complex social interactions

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Adam AlbrightAugust 8, 2017 at 9:42 PM

      Thank you for your response David. I wondered about grace as is evident from the part hahaha.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Hunter class

In last Monday's post I talked about the Thief and mentioned how the “backstab” ability has been moved to the Hunter class. It seems logical to me to cover the Hunter next then. So the Hunter is also found in folklore and fairytales like the Thief.  In Enchanted Kingdoms the hunter will be a character who has been trained in how to survive in the wild. For combat they have the ability to focus in bows and spears or axes and hammers. They also can take a talent that alludes to their time learning about creatures in order to hunt them. This Talent, currently called Predator, lets you roll to see how much you know about a creature when you encounter it. Each creature will have a small table that shows what information the character knows about the creature/monster and it’s abilities.  Hunters start with talents that give them bonuses to hiding and to fighting side by side with their allies. Over time they can expand their abilities to deal damage and impede the movement of their...
2 comments
Read more

D&D 4e with Enchantress sneak peek mixed in

A somewhat non Enchanted Worlds update today.  I recently discovered Matthew Colville on youtube.  He creates some great videos that detail tips for running games.  He is very eloquent and has worked in the game industry so he has the ability to address games from multiple perspectives. If you are thinking about running a game there is a plethora of invaluable tips in his videos.   I bring this up because I found him because of a video that actually puts into words the things that I loved about 4 th edition.  You can watch the whole video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoELQ7px9ws&index=31&list=PLlUk42GiU2guNzWBzxn7hs8MaV7ELLCP_ Now this is a long video, clocking in at almost an hour. I watch youtube at 2x speed so its not as long from that perspective. But again it is crammed with information.  He even touches briefly on some of the strengths of 5 th edition that I can actually respect.  I will most likely come back to thi...
4 comments
Read more

Release Schedule and Thief Class

So there have been a lot of changes in my life, goals, and schedule since my last post.  In my first post I mentioned wanting to post daily, that has been changed to weekly. There is still the possibility of a second post in a week if I think of something I really, really want to write about immediately, but that will be more an exception as opposed to the rule. This is to hopefully avoid burnout, a problem I am well acquainted with from past endeavors. A friend suggested this course of action and I have chosen to act on that suggestion. Secondly I have started a new certification course for my work that will be taking a lot more time than I had initially thought.  The course will be a major focus of mine up until I take the exam in July.  My hopes of possibly getting a Kickstarter up in November are gone, and February is much less likely.  I am probably going to shoot for mid to late summer 2018 at this point so that I can focus on my studies.   This is...
3 comments
Read more